Hawker News

Show HN: I turned my iPhone and a $20 smart plug into an f-stop timer

peterszentkiralyi.eu

86 pointsby pentakkusu39 comments

I am a film photographer and do some darkroom printing and always wanted one of the proper, advanced f-stop timers, but never really wanted to spend a couple hundred dollars on one. Eventually I figured my phone was already perfectly capable of doing the timing, it just needed a way to switch the enlarger.

So I built Darkplug around a cheap smart plug. The app controls the enlarger over the local network and does regular timing, f-stop timing, test strips, has an intuitive dodge/burn workflow, split grade (2 timing channels) and paper development timing.

I’ve been using it for a few months in my improvised bathroom darkroom.

Fair warning: the app was blindly vibe coded using Codex and Xcode.

arnarbi[14 comments hidden]
Very cool. Is it controlling the plugs via direct Bluetooth connection? Or zigbee via a hub, or wifi (direct or via service)?

I always assumed, probably incorrectly, that there would be too much jitter in the actual timing so I had built a few prototypes of e.g. an esp8266 controlled relay, where you would give the MCU a duration rather than separate on/off commands. But I guess that was wildly over-optimizing. In your case, how stable is the delay from the app sending a command until the switch operates?

I'd add voice mode for color printing in total darkness.

jrflo[11 comments hidden]
I was curious about timing accuracy too, has any testing been done on this? Is it accurate to 1s, 0.1s, 0.01s? How dependent is it on the smart switch hardware?
muhehe[4 comments hidden]
I played with development photos in a darkroom a long time ago. I don't think one second actually makes much difference.
guax[3 comments hidden]
Depends on how powerful of a light you’re using. 1 second on a 7 second exposure is too much. One second on a 20, not.
aw4rzs[2 comments hidden]
I don't think 1 second on a 7 second B+W exposure is that noticeable.
guax[hidden]
14% is a lot.

I think you can work around it very easily by stopping down the lens and using filters.

But I’m sure if the phone has direct connection to the device and not working through hubs it’s not anywhere near 1s of delay.

alnwlsn[4 comments hidden]
I'd probably put the typical smart switch hardware/software stack at around 0.25 seconds. Maybe you can but I don't think I'd try to rely on anything much faster than that.

If you did, I would go in the custom firmware for the smart switch direction. A lot of them are just an ESP32 inside, and you could probably get to 0.001 seconds that way (but you are switching AC which cycles on the order of 0.02 seconds, so whatever)

quickthrowman[3 comments hidden]
If I were to tackle this project, I’d use an ESP32 and a relay with 120V contacts. That way you can use a GFCI receptacle and be code compliant if your darkroom is in a basement or the enlarger receptacle is near your darkroom sink.
pathartl[hidden]
If you buy something like the Sonoff S31 they have an 8266 in them that can be easily flashed
pentakkusu[hidden]
Many such projects were actually made, some of them are better documented then others. For this application I wanted something that is as off the shelf as possible.
foobar1962[hidden]
Repeatability is more important than accuracy.

Note also that some of the best printers used metronomes to count exposure time and turn the enlarger light on and off manually.

pentakkusu[hidden]
Using slow motion recording, I measured 0.1s accuracy. I'd say it's more than good enough. You can see a print on the website I made with the app and a smart plug. The average print needs between 4-60s of exposure.

As for how dependent it is on that specific type of hardware (Shelly plugs), it is 100% dependent as the app directly controls the smart plug (with the help of the router ofc). There is no way around it, no other smart switch family is currently supported.

Crosseye_Jack[hidden]
> How it works

> Set up your smart plug and note its local IP address. Make sure the plug and your iPhone or iPad share the same local network. Connect your enlarger to the smart plug. Enter the plug’s local IP address in Darkplug, and connect. Once set up, you can control the enlarger directly from your iPhone or iPad.

pentakkusu[hidden]
Voice mode… interesting. Not sure about that. Handsfree operation is traditionally done with foot switches in the darkroom. You mean like “hey Siri, expose for 8 seconds”?
pimlottc[11 comments hidden]
I get that red-on-black color scheme is a nod to the red lighting of a dark room, but the contrast is so low I can hardly read the example screenshots.
baoooooooooooo[3 comments hidden]
Isn't it more than a nod, and actually a hard requirement to be considered for use in an active darkroom?

It hadn't occurred to me that now with OLEDs you can actually safely limit exposure to wavelengths that would be damaging to the development process - I'd imagine that is what the author is shooting for here

macintux[2 comments hidden]
I upgraded to an Apple Watch Ultra because it offered a face with only red and black. It’s been long enough now that I don’t remember all the details, but I appreciated being able to monitor time in the darkroom (using DND to avoid flashes of light).
pentakkusu[hidden]
Fun fact, I planned an Apple Watch companion app as well, but the Apple Watch is just too erratic in the way it lights up randomly, no matter what app (live activity?) you run, and there is no way to put a red filter on either.
guax[4 comments hidden]
It’s not a nod. It’s required to not ruin the paper during use. A specific yellow would also work but phone screens often output more than just the desired color. Red is the safest.
pimlottc[3 comments hidden]
That's fine, just make the versions on the website readable for people who aren't in a darkroom.
plussed_reader[2 comments hidden]
What's the use case to use a darkroom tool outside the dark room?
pimlottc[hidden]
I’m talking about the promotional website, not the app
pentakkusu[3 comments hidden]
Trust me, in the dark, your eyes adapt and you will be able to read the GUI just fine. And as someone said, the reason the GUI is like this, is to not emit unnecessary light in the darkroom, thus preventing fogging the paper.
pimlottc[2 comments hidden]
Sorry, I just meant that the example images /on the website/ should be easier to read, not that the screens in the app themselves should be changed.
pentakkusu[hidden]
Note taken. I need to re-do those screenshots anyway, and will bump the contrast on the new ones.
pathartl[2 comments hidden]
I grew up with two photographer parents that built a house around photographic printing. I was looking through their exposure notes a bit ago and as long as you can get sub second you should be able to get some pretty consistent results.

They did color, so when printing there was no such thing as a safelite. I can still vividly remember being that "can I help?" age and setting the timers for each color, loading in the paper in complete darkness, firing up the enlarger, and then feeding it to the auto processor. It was certainly an interesting way to grow up.

pentakkusu[hidden]
So cool. Black and white printing is a different beast, where you can get away with much less precision and you can produce fantastic results by just eyeing things and winging it. I know a printer who operates like this, gauging the developement by a pair of well trained eyes, and know others who treat their darkroom as a scientific laboratory and do density tests and swear by their DIY chemistry etc.

Lot's of ways to do it, in the end, if you enjoy the process, then all is good.

s0rce[2 comments hidden]
25 years ago my dad built me a darkroom timer with a relay and a PIC 16F84A. It only had one button that you used a combination of short and long presses to adjust the time (read on a 7 segment LED display) and trigger the exposure.
s0rce[hidden]
The BOM, schematic and firmware is on Wayback machine if anyone wants to build one!
sailingcode[hidden]
Good idea. I wonder if the iPhone's camera would be able to measure the projected negative and guide exposure time?
nottorp[2 comments hidden]
I'd like to endorse the plug choice :)

Shellys can be configured to connect to your wifi and are not dependent on any cloud service.

pentakkusu[hidden]
Exactly the reason I went with it, and of course the proper documentation on their website was very useful as well.
mmmlinux[2 comments hidden]
25$ to unlock all the features...
pentakkusu[hidden]
Yes. I thought It's fair. Under 50$ for the app and a compatible smart plug vs 300$+ for a boutique hardware enlarger with a narrower feature set.
dofm[hidden]
Nice. I have been meaning to do this with an e-ink device but other distractions keep getting in the way.
Sarkie[4 comments hidden]
I had no idea what an enlarger was.
maciekkmrk[2 comments hidden]
I recently took a B&W film development and printing class and it was very cool. I wouldn't be inclined to do it again, but it was fun to understand what 'dodging' and 'burning' refers too and get your hands do something.
aaronbrethorst[hidden]
The icons for the dodge and burn tools in Photoshop are directly cribbed from the tools you'd use in a darkroom, too ;) https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/desktop/repair-retouch/adj...
pentakkusu[hidden]
Analog photography is a wonderful world and is a great rabbit hole to jump into in this day and age IMHO.